Key Stats for Paycom Stock
- 52-Week Range: $105 to $268
- Current Price: $120
- Street Mean Target: $153
- Street High Target: $240
- TIKR Model Target (Dec. 2030): $175
What Happened?
Paycom Software (PAYC), the Oklahoma City-based human capital management (HCM) platform that automates payroll, time management, and HR workflows on a single database, closed at $119.84 on April 14, sitting 55% below its 52-week high as the market processes a guidance reset that obscures genuine operational progress.
The reset arrived on February 11, when Paycom reported Q4 2025 recurring and other revenues of $517 million, up 11.2% year over year, and guided full-year 2026 total revenue to between $2.175 billion and $2.195 billion, below the analyst consensus of $2.23 billion.
The number that puts that guidance in context is 91%: Paycom’s annual revenue retention rate for 2025, up from 90% in 2024, reflecting the strongest client satisfaction the company has reported in recent years.
Driving that retention improvement is IWant, Paycom’s command-driven AI engine that lets any employee, manager, or executive query HR and payroll data without training, and which Forrester found delivered an ROI of over 400% for organizations that deployed it.
CEO Chad Richison stated on the Q4 2025 earnings call that “IWant usage is up 80% in January alone,” signaling accelerating product adoption at the ground level even as the headline guidance number spooked the market.
Behind the guidance shortfall is a deliberate sales reset: Paycom replaced its chief sales officer in January, expanded its sales teams to 10 from 8 regional groups, and pulled its entire salesforce through retraining on automation messaging before pushing them back into the field.
Paycom returned $455 million to stockholders through dividends and buybacks in 2025, and the board authorized an additional $200 million repurchase in March, partially replenishing the program after approximately $1.45 billion in repurchases since July 2024.
The company still serves less than 5% of its total addressable market, a figure management repeated throughout the earnings call, and the mid-market and upmarket segments where client revenue is growing fastest remain largely untapped.
Wall Street’s Take on PAYC Stock
The guidance cut is the story the market is telling about Paycom stock, but the earnings data tells a different one: a software business generating structurally higher free cash flow while its most powerful AI product gains adoption velocity.
Paycom’s free cash flow reached $404 million in 2025, up 19.6% year over year, with FCF margins expanding 180 basis points to 19.9%, and consensus sees FCF growing to around $480 million in 2026 at an FCF margin approaching 22%.
Seven of 22 analysts rate PAYC a buy or outperform, with 15 holds and no sells; the mean price target sits at $153, implying around 28% upside from the current price, with the Street broadly waiting to see whether the sales retraining converts into new logo adds in the back half of 2026.
The spread between the high target of $240 and the low of $120 reflects a genuine debate: the bull case believes the sales rebuild combined with IWant adoption creates a re-acceleration into 2027, while the low end prices in a prolonged growth stall if the retraining cycle does not close new business before year-end.
With a forward P/E of roughly 12x against consensus EPS growth of around 14% for 2026 and a historical average multiple that has rarely dipped below 20x, Paycom stock appears undervalued as the market assigns a distressed multiple to a business expanding FCF margins and improving client retention simultaneously.
IWant usage rising 80% month over month in January, without any change in the client base, suggests the product adoption curve is steepening in a way that does not yet appear in bookings.
If the 2026 sales retraining does not translate into new logo adds before Q3, recurring revenue growth could fall below the low end of the 7% to 8% guidance range.
New logo additions in Q3 2026 will be the clearest read on whether the sales rebuild is working; watch for recurring revenue growth accelerating past 8% as the signal that the inflection has arrived.
Paycom Stock Financials
Paycom’s recurring and other revenues reached $1.94 billion in 2025, up 10.3% year over year, while total revenues crossed $2.05 billion, extending four consecutive years of double-digit or near-double-digit growth on the top line.
Gross profit grew to $1.79 billion in 2025, up 10.7%, as PAYC’s gross margin recovered to 87.2% from 85.8% in 2024, reversing two years of mild compression and reflecting the internal cost discipline that automation is beginning to generate across the business.
Operating income reached $567 million in 2025, sustaining a 27.6% operating margin against a backdrop of rising R&D spend to support the IWant platform and the expanded data center footprint.
What Does the Valuation Model Say?
TIKR’s mid-case model prices PAYC at around $174 per share by end of 2030, based on a revenue CAGR of around 6% and a net income margin expanding to around 26%, a scenario grounded in the company’s own guidance range and its demonstrated ability to convert top-line growth into expanding margins.
With the stock priced at roughly 12x forward earnings against consensus EPS growth of around 14% and a historical multiple that has rarely dipped this low outside of peak uncertainty, Paycom stock appears undervalued relative to the quality of its cash generation and the durability of its 91% retention base.
The question for PAYC is not whether the business is sound; it is how fast the sales rebuild closes the gap between 6% revenue growth and what this platform is capable of generating.
Low Case: Around $169 per share
- Revenue grows at a around 5% CAGR through 2030, consistent with the low end of guidance compounding without meaningful new logo acceleration
- Net income margins hold near current levels at around 24.5%, as higher sales and marketing spend from the salesforce expansion offsets automation-driven efficiency gains
- The sales retraining and CSO transition extend the new logo drought into 2027, delaying any re-rating of the multiple
- Total return of around 41% over the model period, implying a low single-digit annualized return that barely justifies the risk
Mid Case: Around $215 per share
- Revenue grows at around 6% CAGR, tracking the midpoint of 2026 guidance and assuming modest new logo acceleration in H2 as the retrained salesforce reaches full productivity
- Net income margins expand to around 26%, reflecting the operating leverage embedded in the single-database platform as IWant adoption reduces support costs per client
- IWant usage growth of 80% month over month in January validates the cross-sell thesis, and recurring revenue growth re-accelerates toward 8% by Q4 2026
- Total return of around 79% over the model period at an annualized rate of around 7%
High Case: Around $264 per share
- Revenue grows at around 6.4% CAGR with net income margins reaching around 28%, driven by upmarket traction where revenue from clients over 1,000 employees is already growing faster than total revenue
- The expanded 10-team sales structure and returning CSO Jeff York, who built Paycom’s original sales engine from 2007 to 2021, unlock a disproportionate share of the remaining 95% of the addressable market
- FCF margins approach 26% by 2030 from 19.9% in 2025, converting the automation investment cycle into sustained cash generation that supports continued buybacks well beyond the current $200 million authorization
- Total return of around 120% over the model period at an annualized rate of around 10%
Should You Invest in Paycom Software, Inc.?
The only way to really know is to look at the numbers yourself. TIKR gives you free access to the same institutional-quality financial data that professional analysts use to answer exactly that question.
Pull up PAYC stock and you’ll see years of historical financials, what Wall Street analysts expect for revenue and earnings in the quarters ahead, how valuation multiples have moved over time, and whether price targets are trending up or down.
You can build a free watchlist to track Paycom Software, Inc. alongside every other stock on your radar. No credit card required. Just the data you need to decide for yourself.
Access Professional Tools to Analyze PAYC stock on TIKR for Free →
