Key Stats for Hartford Insurance Stock
- Past-Week Performance: +0.7%
- 52-Week Range: $107.5 to $144.5
- Current Price: $141
What Happened?
The Hartford Insurance Group (HIG) is trading at $141.06, just 2.4% below its 52-week high of $144.50, as a 19.4% core earnings ROE reported on the Q4 earnings call and a 355% decade-long total return highlighted by BofA analyst Joshua Shanker on February 10 that outpaced Travelers, Chubb, CNA, and Cincinnati Financial by approximately 100 percentage points reframe HIG as the P&C industry’s most consistent compounder.
Driving the re-rating, Chairman and CEO Christopher Swift filed two separate common share disposals on February 4 and February 6, while CFO Beth Costello confirmed at the February 10 BofA Securities Financial Services Conference that quarterly share repurchases are stepping up to $450 million starting Q1, signaling deep management conviction in the capital return story.
The engine behind that conviction is a Q4 core earnings print of $1.1 billion at $4.06 per diluted share, anchored by a full-year Business Insurance underlying combined ratio of 88.5%, a 30% surge in E&S binding premium, and net investment income jumping 17% to $832 million on 11.4% annualized LP returns.
Beyond the numbers, the market is actively repricing HIG from a mature insurance utility into a technology-driven compounder, as a decade of platform investment in Guidewire, Duck Creek, and AI-first workflows has produced the #1 Keynova small business digital ranking for seven consecutive years and a 10-year return profile that now commands a structural premium over every comparable peer.
Chairman and CEO Christopher Swift stated on the Q4 earnings call that “I could see it getting below 30% over the next 2 years or by the end of ’27,” contextualizing a Business Insurance expense ratio trajectory that, combined with a Personal Insurance target below 25%, sets up meaningful margin expansion just as Prevail Agency scales to 30 states.
Further reinforcing institutional conviction, analyst Joshua Shanker of BofA Securities spotlighted HIG’s 355% 10-year return at the February 10 conference, directly comparing it against the approximately 255% posted by Travelers, Chubb, CNA, and Cincinnati Financial, framing The Hartford as the clear structural outperformer in a sector facing broad AI disruption headwinds.
Looking 3 to 5 years out, The Hartford’s combination of a $1.9 billion catastrophe reinsurance program, $450 million quarterly buybacks, Prevail Agency expanding nationally, and an AI-first infrastructure already embedded across claims, underwriting, and operations positions HIG to widen its competitive moat precisely when undercapitalized peers will struggle most to match its technology investment scale.
Wall Street’s Take on HIG Stock
The Hartford‘s decision to raise quarterly buybacks to $450 million starting Q1, declare a $0.60 per share dividend, and project $2.9 billion in operating company dividends for 2026 directly confirms that management views the current price as an active capital deployment opportunity rather than a ceiling.
Beneath the capital return story, the fundamentals show a business that peaked on growth but held margins, as full-year 2025 EBIT surged 24% to $5.0 billion with a 17.6% EBIT margin, while forward 2026 estimates project a modest EBIT compression to $4.94 billion at a still-strong 16.6% margin alongside flat EPS of $13.42.
Wall Street holds a cautiously constructive stance with 7 buys, 4 outperforms, and 12 holds among 23 analysts, while the mean price target of $150.85 implies 6.9% upside from the current price of $141.06, suggesting analysts are maintaining conviction through a soft-growth period rather than aggressively upgrading into fresh momentum.
The spread between the analyst low target of $135 and the high of $163 is meaningful, with the bear case hinging on casualty loss trend deterioration and social inflation persistence, while the bull case requires Prevail Agency’s 30-state expansion and Employee Benefits’ 45% to 50% known sales growth to translate into sustained top-line reacceleration through 2026.
What Does the Valuation Model Say?
Given the 19.4% core earnings ROE, accelerating buybacks, and a $2.9 billion dividend pipeline from operating companies, TIKR’s mid-case model pricing HIG at $216.78 with a 53.7% total return and a 9.3% annualized IRR over 5.8 years reflects a credible compounding story for patient capital rather than a near-term momentum trade.
The single most consequential risk is forward EPS growth stalling at 0.0% for 2026, as net income normalizes from $3.85 billion to $3.71 billion, and any further casualty loss trend deterioration or social inflation acceleration could compress margins faster than the AI-driven expense ratio improvements management is targeting by end of 2027.
At $141.06, HIG looks fairly valued in the near term but modestly undervalued on a 3 to 5-year horizon, with the Prevail Agency national rollout, $450 million quarterly buybacks, and expense ratio targets below 30% for Business Insurance serving as the key inflection points that will determine whether the stock closes the gap to the $150.85 analyst mean target.
Should You Invest in Hartford Insurance Group, Inc.?
The only way to really know is to look at the numbers yourself. TIKR gives you free access to the same institutional-quality financial data that professional analysts use to answer exactly that question.
Pull up HIG stock and you’ll see years of historical financials, what Wall Street analysts expect for revenue and earnings in the quarters ahead, how valuation multiples have moved over time, and whether price targets are trending up or down.
You can build a free watchlist to track Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. alongside every other stock on your radar. No credit card required. Just the data you need to decide for yourself.
Access Professional Tools to Analyze HIG stock on TIKR for Free →
