Is Nutrien Stock Still Undervalued After Its Record Potash Quarter?

David Beren8 minute read
Reviewed by: Thomas Richmond
Last updated Oct 29, 2025

Nutrien Ltd. (NTR) remains one of the world’s largest providers of crop inputs and agricultural services, supplying farmers with potash, nitrogen, and phosphate fertilizers that support global food security. Through its vertically integrated model, spanning production, distribution, and retail, the company has built a resilient supply chain that can adapt to shifts in regional demand and pricing cycles. Its global retail network provides an additional buffer against commodity volatility, making Nutrien a critical player in the agricultural value chain.

Discover how much upside your favorite stocks could have using TIKR’s new Valuation Model (It’s free) >>>

The fertilizer market in 2025 continues to reflect aftershocks from the pandemic-era supply crunch, the war in Ukraine, and logistical bottlenecks in Eastern Europe. Global potash inventories remain tight, while project delays in Africa and South America have slowed the addition of new capacity.

At the same time, persistent weather disruptions have complicated planting cycles, boosting fertilizer demand in the Western Hemisphere. For Nutrien, this combination of tight supply and steady demand has helped stabilize margins and restore earnings growth after a volatile 2023–24 cycle.

Nutrien valuation model
Nutrien’s valuation model indicates slow but steady growth ahead of 2027. (TIKR)

Despite its strong fundamentals, Nutrien’s share price has lagged its commodity peers, reflecting lingering investor caution about the durability of fertilizer prices. With shares up roughly 21% year-to-date, the market is gradually pricing in recovery, but the company’s ability to sustain growth will depend on disciplined capital spending, improving global demand, and a smooth transition toward low-carbon ammonia and sustainable nutrient production, two areas where Nutrien is investing heavily.

Quickly value any stock with TIKR’s powerful new Valuation Model (It’s free!) >>>

Financial Story

Nutrien reported second-quarter 2025 net earnings of $1.2 billion ($2.50 per share) and adjusted EBITDA of $2.5 billion, up strongly from the prior year. First-half adjusted EBITDA reached $3.3 billion, fueled by record potash sales volumes, higher nitrogen prices, and improved production efficiency. The company’s balance sheet remains solid, with ongoing cash generation supporting dividends and share repurchases totaling $800 million in the first half of 2025.

MetricQ2 2025Q2 2024YoY Change
Net Earnings$1.2B$1.0B+20%
Adjusted EBITDA$2.5B$2.2B+14%
Adjusted EPS$2.65$2.30+15%
Potash EBITDA$1.1B$0.9B+22%
Nitrogen EBITDA$1.1B$1.0B+10%
Retail EBITDA$1.2B$1.1B+9%
Share Buybacks$316M$—New
Potash Sales Guidance13.9–14.5M tonnes13.3M tonnesRaised

Operationally, Nutrien’s performance was marked by record reliability, with its nitrogen segment achieving a 98% ammonia operating rate, the highest in company history. Potash adjusted EBITDA increased to $1.1 billion, supported by strong demand in North America and key offshore markets such as Brazil, India, and Indonesia. Nitrogen-adjusted EBITDA also rose to $1.1 billion, while retail operations contributed $1.2 billion despite challenging conditions in Australia and parts of the U.S. Midwest. The company’s focus on operating efficiency and balanced exposure across segments helped offset regional headwinds.

CEO Ken Seitz reiterated Nutrien’s confidence in the outlook for the remainder of 2025, highlighting stable demand, disciplined capital management, and market share gains in potash. The company raised its full-year potash sales volume guidance to 13.9–14.5 million tonnes, reflecting a strong forward order book and sustained global demand. Management maintained all other operational guidance ranges, signaling optimism for steady performance into 2026.

Look up Nutrien’s full financial results & estimates (It’s free) >>>

1. Potash Strength Remains the Core Growth Engine

Potash remains Nutrien’s most reliable earnings driver and competitive advantage. As the world’s largest producer, the company has captured upside from sustained global demand while maintaining pricing discipline. Tight supply from Belarus and Russia, combined with infrastructure bottlenecks in key export regions, has supported a favorable pricing environment. Nutrien’s ability to maintain record sales volumes while managing logistics and production costs demonstrates the scalability of its low-cost Canadian operations.

Looking ahead, Nutrien’s raised volume guidance reflects not just near-term demand strength but growing confidence in its ability to execute operationally. The company has made significant progress in automation, capacity optimization, and energy efficiency, allowing it to meet new global demand at a lower cost base. As emerging markets in Asia and Latin America expand agricultural output, Nutrien’s potash exports will remain vital in balancing global fertilizer supply and demand through 2026.

2. Nitrogen and Retail Businesses Add Stability

Nutrien’s nitrogen operations continue to perform exceptionally well, driven by record ammonia production rates and higher selling prices. The segment benefits from strategic asset placement in North America, where access to low-cost natural gas provides a structural advantage over competitors. Demand from industrial and agricultural customers has stayed firm, while ongoing debottlenecking efforts across Nutrien’s nitrogen facilities are expected to unlock additional production capacity in 2026. This operational efficiency has provided consistent cash flow even as pricing moderates from peak 2022 levels.

Meanwhile, Nutrien’s retail business, with more than 2,000 locations globally, remains a stabilizing force amid fertilizer market swings. Despite challenging weather in Australia and the southern U.S., retail sales volumes in North America improved year over year, supported by increased demand for crop nutrients. The segment’s growing digital platform and localized advisory services continue to strengthen its customer base and margins. Longer-term, Nutrien’s retail network offers an underappreciated source of earnings resilience, providing insulation against volatility in its commodity-linked segments.

Value stocks like Nutrien in less than 60 seconds with TIKR (It’s free) >>>

3. Cash Flow Discipline and Shareholder Returns

Nutrien’s focus on capital discipline and cash flow generation has become a central theme for investors. The company generated significant free cash flow in the first half of 2025, which funded both organic investments and shareholder returns. With $0.8 billion returned through dividends and buybacks, Nutrien reaffirmed its commitment to maintaining a competitive yield while reducing leverage. This disciplined approach allows for opportunistic capital deployment in low-carbon ammonia, precision agriculture, and nitrogen-efficiency technologies.

In addition, Nutrien’s management has maintained a cautious stance on major acquisitions, preferring internal efficiency projects and incremental growth over aggressive expansion. This conservative posture is resonating well with investors following prior periods of overextension across the fertilizer industry. By balancing growth with returns, Nutrien has re-established itself as one of the most reliable income-generating plays in the basic materials sector. This position could strengthen further as markets stabilize into 2026.

The TIKR Takeaway

Nutrien YTD
Nutrien’s YTD performance is boosting the conversation that 2025 was a turnaround year. (TIKR)

Nutrien’s 2025 turnaround story illustrates how operational excellence and disciplined capital allocation can restore confidence in a cyclical industry. The company has effectively leveraged its potash leadership and nitrogen production strength to rebuild profitability while delivering shareholder value through consistent dividends and buybacks. Its performance is proof that efficiency and diversification can offset volatility even in one of the world’s most unpredictable commodity sectors.

Looking ahead, the key question for investors is whether Nutrien can sustain these gains as fertilizer markets normalize. Continued cost optimization, measured capacity growth, and investment in low-emission production will define its competitive edge. If the company executes well, 2026 could mark the start of a steadier growth phase, one where Nutrien’s mix of stability and innovation positions it ahead of peers.

Should You Buy, Sell, or Hold Nutrien Stock in 2025?

With robust fundamentals, raised potash guidance, and a clear focus on shareholder value, Nutrien looks attractively priced for long-term investors. The company’s dividend yield and buyback program add meaningful support for total returns, while its operational leverage to global food demand remains compelling. Fertilizer prices are cyclical, but Nutrien’s balance sheet strength and diversified model provide solid downside protection.

How Much Upside Does Nutrien Stock Have From Here?

With TIKR’s new Valuation Model tool, you can estimate a stock’s potential share price in under a minute.

All it takes is three simple inputs:

  1. Revenue Growth
  2.  Operating Margins
  3.  Exit P/E Multiple

If you’re not sure what to enter, TIKR automatically fills in each input using analysts’ consensus estimates, giving you a quick, reliable starting point.

From there, TIKR calculates the potential share price and total returns under Bull, Base, and Bear scenarios so you can quickly see whether a stock looks undervalued or overvalued.

Estimate a company’s fair value instantly (Free with TIKR) >>>

Looking for New Opportunities?

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required