Key Takeaways
- Peter Thiel’s Thiel Macro sold all four of its regulated utilities in the third quarter, including American Electric Power and DTE Energy, and opened a $161 million position in the iShares Semiconductor ETF, now its largest holding.
- The fund added 59% to its shares of the Argentine oil producer, which makes it 26.8% of its 13F.
- The Argentine oil producer trades at about 5x forward earnings, and analysts’ average target is 85% above the stock.
- Of all the fund’s moves, the numbers support the Argentine oil buy best, and AEP’s rising targets make it the sale that’s easiest to question.
By Sept. 30, Peter Thiel’s fund had sold its utilities and bought more chips and Argentine oil. Thiel Macro’s 13F for the quarter ended Sept. 30, filed Nov. 16, shows a 59% bigger stake in the Argentine oil producer, a new position in the iShares Semiconductor ETF, and no shares left in American Electric Power (AEP) or DTE Energy (DTE).
That’s a lot of change for a small portfolio. The 13F holds $460 million of US stocks in five positions, down from eight at June 30. Thiel Macro reported no US stocks at all at March 31, so nothing in it goes back more than two filings.
A $161 million bet on chips
The biggest move is a new one. The iShares Semiconductor ETF is now the fund’s largest position, worth $161.0 million at Sept. 30, or 35.0% of the 13F. The four utilities the fund sold were worth $162.0 million at June 30, so the two are almost exactly the same size. The filing doesn’t say whether one paid for the other. Chips are familiar ground for this fund: Thiel Macro sold all 537,742 of its Nvidia shares in the third quarter of 2025, and its June 30 filing held no chip stocks at all. Amazon, Vistra and X-energy make up the rest of the five positions.
TIKR tracks 12 analysts on Vista Energy (VIST). How many say “Buy”?
See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on Vista Energy, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See Vista Energy’s Analyst Ratings
Vista got bigger, then cheaper
Vista is the one stock the fund added to. At Sept. 30 it held 1.89 million of Vista’s US-listed shares, 59% more than at June 30. They were worth $123 million, or 26.8% of the 13F, its third-biggest position. The stock is down 21% since Sept. 30 and sits 36% below its 52-week high. (That’s the stock’s move. The filing doesn’t show what the fund paid.)
The drop came after a strong quarter. In its third-quarter results on Oct. 28, Vista said production rose 33% from a year earlier to 169,023 barrels of oil equivalent a day, at a realized oil price of $84.20 a barrel.
That leaves Vista at about 5x forward earnings, which is cheap for a company growing production by a third. The 12 analysts who cover it have an average target of $96.07, 85% above the last close. The main risk is that Vista’s earnings move with the oil price, and at more than a quarter of the fund, it’s a big bet on one producer.
The utilities are all gone
All four of the fund’s regulated utilities are gone from the 13F: AEP, DTE, FirstEnergy and CMS Energy. None of them was in the March 31 filing either, so each one appears in just one 13F. AEP was the largest, with 308,617 shares worth $42.2 million at June 30, or 10.1% of the fund at the time. The other three were each worth between $39.6 million and $40.3 million.
AEP stock is down 8% since June 30, the last time the fund’s 13F showed it, and sits 10% below its 52-week high. Analysts have moved the other way. AEP’s consensus target rose over the past year, from $127.32 to $141.61:

The average target from the 23 analysts who cover AEP is 12% above the last close. Even the lowest target, $126.00, is right at the $126.50 close. Since the quarter ended, AEP reported higher third-quarter earnings and raised its long-term growth target. At about 19x forward earnings with a 3.1% yield, it isn’t cheap, but its targets are rising.
DTE’s targets held steady
DTE was the second-biggest of the utilities: 264,450 shares worth $40.3 million at June 30, or 9.6% of the fund. It’s down 10% from that June 30 price. During the quarter, though, DTE fell to a 52-week low of $120.83 on Sept. 28, and it has since climbed back to $136.86. The 13F doesn’t say when in the quarter the fund sold. DTE’s consensus target barely moved over the year, from $150.54 to $150.96:

That target, from 17 analysts, is 10% above the close. DTE’s third quarter was solid. Operating earnings came to $2.30 a share, management said it’s on track for the high end of its 2026 guidance of $7.59-$7.73, and it raised its long-term growth target. The stock trades at about 17x forward earnings and yields 3.6%. The risk is regulators: DTE needs approved rates to pay for its bigger plan, and several of those decisions are still pending.
Vista is the move I’d follow
Of everything the fund did last quarter, the Vista buy is the one I’d copy. The stock trades at about 5x forward earnings, production is up a third, and the Street’s average target is 85% above the price. That leaves an investor some room to be wrong. It’s also the riskiest position in the 13F, so I’d keep the position small.
The utility sales are harder to judge. With DTE’s targets flat for a year, that sale is easy to understand. AEP is the one I’d have kept, since its targets kept climbing.
Thiel Macro’s next 13F, for the quarter ending Dec. 31, is due in mid-February. It’ll show whether Vista is still more than a quarter of the fund and whether the chip ETF is still its biggest position. Vista’s fourth-quarter report, due early next year, needs to show production holding above the third quarter’s 169,023 barrels of oil equivalent a day.
So what is Vista Energy stock actually worth?
TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what Vista Energy could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!