Key Takeaways:
- Market Leader: Progressive delivered an impressive 89.5% combined ratio in Q3, adding 4.2 million policyholders year-over-year.
- Price Projection: Based on current fundamentals, the stock could reach $229 by December 2027.
- Potential Gains: This target implies a total return of 13% from the current price of $203.
- Annual Return: Investors could see roughly 6% annual growth over the next 1.9 years.
Now Live: Discover how much upside your favorite stocks could have using TIKR’s new Valuation Model (It’s free)>>>
Progressive (PGR) continues to dominate the auto insurance market with exceptional performance. The company achieved a 10% premium growth rate and 12% policies-in-force growth in Q3. This translates to nearly 7 million more vehicles insured compared to a year ago.
But the real story is Florida.
- The state’s tort reform, enacted through House Bill 837, has dramatically improved the company’s profitability.
- Average loss costs for injury claims dropped between 10% and 20%, while lawsuits fell by 60%.
- This led Progressive to recognize a $950 million policyholder credit expense for excess profits.
Despite strong competition and a mild hurricane season, Progressive’s market position remains solid. The company delivered $10 billion in comprehensive income year-to-date, up over 30% from 2024. Its trailing 12-month return on equity stands at 37.1%.
At $203, PGR stock offers modest upside for investors who understand the company’s shift toward capturing affluent customers while maintaining its competitive edge in price-sensitive segments.
See analysts’ full growth forecasts and estimates for PGR stock (It’s free) >>>
What the Model Says for Progressive Stock
We analyzed Progressive through the lens of CEO Susan Griffith’s strategic vision: expanding into the “Robinsons” segment—affluent, multi-car households that represent a $230 billion addressable market where Progressive has low market share.
The company is well-positioned for growth with improved property margins (78% combined ratio) and readiness to expand in 33 states. This includes 20 growth states and 13 more volatile markets where the company will take a measured approach.
Using a forecast of 9.5% annual revenue growth and 13.3% operating margins, our model projects the stock will rise to $229 within 1.9 years. This assumes a 12.2x Price-to-Earnings multiple, representing compression from Progressive’s current P/E of 12.5x.
As the company navigates heightened competition and strategic rate reductions in Florida, some multiple compression is reasonable. The real value comes from sustained growth in higher-value customer segments and maintaining underwriting discipline.
Our Valuation Assumptions
Estimate a company’s fair value instantly (Free with TIKR) >>>
Our Valuation Assumptions
TIKR’s Valuation Model lets you plug in your own assumptions for a company’s revenue growth, operating margins, and P/E multiple, and calculates the stock’s expected returns.
Here’s what we used for PGR stock:
1. Revenue Growth: 9.5%
Progressive’s growth engine benefits from several key factors working together.
Robinson Expansion: The company is targeting affluent multi-car households with enhanced property bundling capabilities. With property combined ratios at 78%, Progressive has significant room to grow this segment.
Florida Opportunity: Despite recognizing excess profits, Florida remains Progressive’s largest market. The company is the leading provider there, and plans continued growth with competitive pricing following tort reform benefits.
Market Share Gains: Progressive added 4.2 million policies year over year, even as growth rates normalized from record 2024 levels.
New Product Rollouts: Progressive continues refining its pricing models (versions 8.9 and 9.0) with better segmentation and new coverages, such as embedded renters insurance and Progressive Vehicle Protection.
2. Operating margins: 13.3%
Progressive operates with strong margins supported by disciplined underwriting.
Current Performance: The company delivered a combined ratio of 89.5% in Q3, even after including the $950 million Florida excess profits accrual. Year-to-date combined ratio stands at 87.3%.
Pricing Discipline: While competition has intensified, Progressive maintains its target of growing as fast as possible. The company currently has a substantial margin cushion.
Telematics Advantage: Progressive’s extensive driving data and telematics capabilities allow for more precise pricing than competitors. The company has billions of miles of driving data to continuously refine its models.
3. Exit P/E Multiple: 12.2x
The market currently values Progressive at 12.5x earnings. We chose 12.2x for our exit multiple to stay conservative.
Below Historical Average: Progressive’s P/E has averaged 15.8x over the past year and 17.7x over 10 years. The current multiple reflects strong recent performance but accounts for normalizing growth rates.
Build your own Valuation Model to value any stock (It’s free!) >>>
What Happens If Things Go Better or Worse?
Auto insurers face challenges from heightened competition and potential cost inflation. Here’s how Progressive stock might perform under different scenarios through December 2027:
- Low Case: If revenue growth slows to 7.4% and net income margins compress to 8.7%, the stock still offers a 1.1% annual return.
- Mid Case: With 8.2% growth and 9.2% net margins, we expect an annual return of 6.6%.
- High Case: If Robinson segment penetration accelerates and Progressive maintains 9.6% margins while growing at 9.0%, returns could hit 11.6% annually.
See what analysts think about PGR stock right now (Free with TIKR) >>>
The range reflects different outcomes for Progressive’s affluent customer strategy and competitive dynamics.
In the low case, competitors successfully capture market share through aggressive pricing.
In the high case, Progressive’s data advantages and property bundling capabilities drive superior growth in high-value segments.
How Much Upside Does Progressive Stock Have From Here?
With TIKR’s new Valuation Model tool, you can estimate a stock’s potential share price in under a minute.
All it takes is three simple inputs:
- Revenue Growth
- Operating Margins
- Exit P/E Multiple
If you’re not sure what to enter, TIKR automatically fills in each input using analysts’ consensus estimates, giving you a quick, reliable starting point.
From there, TIKR calculates the potential share price and total returns under Bull, Base, and Bear scenarios so you can quickly see whether a stock looks undervalued or overvalued.
See a stock’s true value in under 60 seconds (Free with TIKR) >>>
Looking for New Opportunities?
- See what stocks billionaire investors are buying so you can follow the smart money.
- Analyze stocks in as little as 5 minutes with TIKR’s all-in-one, easy-to-use platform.
- The more rocks you overturn… the more opportunities you’ll uncover. Search 100K+ global stocks, global top investor holdings, and more with TIKR.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!
