Better Dividend Stock for Retirees: Plains All American vs. Hershey

Roxanna Maglangit • 6 minute read
Reviewed by: Michael Douglass
Last updated Nov 20, 2026

curraheeshutter from Getty Images and Violka08 from Getty Images via Canva

Key Takeaways

  • Plains All American yields 6.8% at its current $1.67-a-unit distribution, twice Hershey’s 3.4%.
  • Plains covered its fiscal 2025 distribution 1.7x with distributable cash flow, and Hershey’s dividends took 53% of its free cash flow over the twelve months to Sept. 27, 2026.
  • Plains’ distribution is still below the $2.78 a unit it paid in fiscal 2015, after cuts took it to $0.72 by fiscal 2020.
  • Hershey carries far less debt, at 1.5x net debt to EBITDA against 3.4x for Plains, and Plains gives its 2027 guidance in February.

Retirees hunting for income want a dividend check they can count on, and Plains All American Pipeline (PAA) and Hershey (HSY) offer very different versions of one.

Plains yields 6.8%, and the $0.4175 a unit it declared on Oct. 1 for the third quarter is 10% more than a year earlier. Hershey yields half as much, and on Oct. 29 it raised its 2026 earnings outlook even as it trimmed its sales forecast.

So which check belongs in a retiree’s portfolio?

MetricPlains All American (PAA)Hershey (HSY)
Dividend yield6.8%3.4%
Annual dividend$1.67 a unit$5.81 a share
Dividend growth, fiscal 2020-202516.7% a year11.7% a year
Dividend growth, fiscal 2015-2025-5.6% a year9.4% a year
Coverage, on its own measure1.7x distributable cash flow coverage (fiscal 2025)53% cash dividend payout ratio (TTM)
Net debt / EBITDA (LTM)3.4x1.5x
Interest coverage (LTM)2.8x11.7x
Source: TIKR; current dividend rates from StockAnalysis. Yields at today’s prices

6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields

There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.

But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.

They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.

Plains has room to keep raising

Plains is a partnership, so it pays distributions on units, with a K-1 at tax time. Like other pipelines, it’s judged on distributable cash flow. In fiscal 2025, it generated $2.61 a unit of distributable cash flow against $1.56 paid out, a comfortable 1.7x coverage. The cushion has narrowed as the payout grew:

Bar chart from TIKR of Plains All American Pipeline's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025.
Plains All American Pipeline (PAA): distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025 (TIKR)

Coverage went from 3.2x in fiscal 2020 to 1.7x in fiscal 2025. That’s still far wider than the 1.1x of fiscal 2017, the year the distribution fell from $2.50 to $1.70.

Management’s plan is to “return cash to unitholders through our targeted $0.15 per unit annual increases.” Since that’s a fixed amount, each raise will be a smaller percentage than the last.

The business can fund it. Adjusted EBITDA rose 6% to $711 million in the third quarter of 2026 from a year earlier. Plains also stood by its $2.88 billion full-year guidance despite a GAAP loss of $0.06 a unit. By Oct. 9, it had redeemed all its preferred units, which Plains expects to add about $0.09 a unit of distributable cash flow a year. The catch: it paid for that partly with $1.5 billion of junior subordinated notes, and it put its pro forma leverage at about 3.6x at the end of September.

Hershey grows its check with less debt

Plains’ distribution shrank over the past decade, while Hershey’s rose from $2.24 a share in fiscal 2015 to $5.48 in fiscal 2025, or 9.4% a year. Its current rate is $5.81. Hershey pays from free cash flow, and over the twelve months to Sept. 27, 2026, dividends took a well-covered 53% of it: $1.13 billion of $2.12 billion. That cushion has thinned too:

Bar chart from TIKR of Hershey Company's free cash flow vs. common dividends paid, $ billions, fiscal 2016–2025.
Hershey Company (HSY): free cash flow vs. common dividends paid, $ billions, fiscal 2016–2025 (TIKR)

Dividends paid rose from $0.69 billion in fiscal 2021 to $1.09 billion in fiscal 2025. That’s faster than free cash flow, which went from $1.59 billion to $1.82 billion.

Sales are the soft spot. Third-quarter net sales rose 3.0% to $3.28 billion, but just 0.8% organically at constant currency. Hershey narrowed its 2026 organic growth forecast to about 3%, from 3% to 3.5%. It also raised its adjusted EPS guidance to $8.58-$8.74, from $8.36-$8.52, helped partly by tariff refunds and lower cocoa costs.

CEO Kirk Tanner said its second-half demand creation initiatives are “gaining momentum, even as consumers grow more cautious.” Shoppers squeezed by gas prices and inflation are the main risk to that growth.

So which dividend wins?

Plains All American is the better dividend stock for retirees: its check is twice the size, and its cash covers it with room to spare. Put $10,000 in Plains, and it pays $683 a year today, against $340 from Hershey. At either company’s 5-year growth rate, or at its pace in fiscal 2025, Hershey’s income never catches up.

The worry with Plains is debt, which ran much higher around its cuts:

Bar chart from TIKR of Plains All American Pipeline's net debt to EBITDA (x), fiscal 2016-2025.
Plains All American Pipeline (PAA): net debt to EBITDA (x), fiscal 2016-2025 (TIKR)

Net debt was 7.9x EBITDA in fiscal 2016 and 5.6x in fiscal 2020. It’s 3.4x over the last twelve months, down from 4.7x in fiscal 2025, after Plains sold its Canadian NGL business in May.

This isn’t to say Hershey is the wrong pick. It carries 1.5x net debt to EBITDA, covers its interest 11.7x against Plains’ 2.8x, and grew its dividend through the decade when Plains’ shrank. A retiree who never wants to see a cut has good reason to choose it.

It’s just that, with coverage at 1.7x and leverage near its decade lows, Plains has earned back enough trust. Twice the income is a lot to leave on the table.

Of course, Plains gives its 2027 guidance on its February call, and if Permian growth slows, its raises could too.

Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields

Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.

Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.

We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.

Learn more here.

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required