Key Takeaways
- Of the 460 big funds that have filed 13Fs for the September quarter, 14 bought Coherent and 13 sold, including Ken Fisher’s Fisher Investments, which cut its stake 49%.
- The biggest seller, Electron Capital Partners, sold all of its Coherent and Keysight shares.
- The case against Coherent is its cash flow: operating cash flow was negative in the September quarter, after $1.0 billion of negative free cash flow in fiscal 2026.
- Analysts expect normalized EPS to nearly double in fiscal 2027. With the stock at 18x forward earnings, below its 24x five-year average, the buyers have the better case.
Big funds split almost evenly on Coherent (COHR) last quarter, and so far the sellers look smarter. The stock is down 25% since Sept. 30. (A 13F doesn’t show what anyone paid, so that’s only the stock’s move.)
The funds’ 13Fs for the quarter ended Sept. 30, filed by Nov. 16, show that 14 big funds bought and 13 sold. Ken Fisher’s Fisher Investments was one of the sellers. The counts cover the 460 big funds that have filed so far, meaning funds readers know or funds with $1 billion or more of US stocks in their 13Fs, with quant and index funds left out. Of those 460, 27 held Coherent at the quarter’s end.
TIKR tracks 27 analysts on Coherent. How many say “Buy”?
See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on Coherent, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See Coherent’s Analyst Ratings
Electron made the biggest exit
Fisher Investments, which manages $386.67 billion, cut its stake 49% to 133,471 shares, according to its 13F filed Nov. 6. The sale came to about $36 million of stock at quarter-end prices. What’s left is worth $38 million and is Fisher’s No. 263 holding out of 1,054, so Coherent was never a big bet there.
The sale that stands out came from Electron Capital Partners, which manages $4.2 billion. Its 13F, filed Nov. 16, shows it sold out of Coherent and eight other sizable positions. That included all 277,072 of its Coherent shares, a stake worth $109 million and 4.4% of its 13F stocks at June 30. One of the other exits was Keysight (KEYS), a $70 million stake that was 2.8% of its 13F stocks at June 30. Ardmore Road Asset Management, which manages $2.8 billion, also sold all 75,000 of its Coherent shares, a $30 million stake at June 30.
Three buyers made it a real position
The buying was more spread out, but three funds made Coherent a meaningful holding by Sept. 30. Munro Partners, whose 13F holds $4.2 billion of US stocks, opened a new position of 166,761 shares worth $48 million, or 1.1% of its 13F stocks. DSM Capital Partners, which manages $7.6 billion, added 35% to reach 242,249 shares worth $70 million. Clough Capital Partners, which manages $1.5 billion, raised its stake more than fivefold to 74,902 shares, or 1.9% of its 13F stocks. Lee Ainslie’s Maverick Capital added 79% as well, though its 4,145 shares are a small position.
DSM also kept its Keysight shares, adding 4% to a $100 million stake that is its No. 17 holding. Keysight is down 23% since Sept. 30, close to Coherent’s drop, so the selloff has hit more than one stock in the industry. The 12 analysts covering Keysight have an average target of $419, which is 49% above its last close.
Coherent’s own insiders have been buying too. Two of them bought $1.2 million of stock when the stock was 47% below its high.
Analysts keep raising the numbers
The buyers have the earnings on their side. Coherent’s September-quarter revenue rose 50% from a year earlier to a record $2.37 billion. Management still expects its first $3 billion quarter by the end of fiscal 2027, in June. Analysts expect normalized EPS to rise to $10.37 in fiscal 2027, from $5.61 in fiscal 2026, and to $15.78 in fiscal 2028:

The fiscal 2027 estimate was $8.17 at June 30, and analysts have raised it since then, including after the September-quarter report.
The stock still trades at 18x forward earnings. That’s below its five-year average of 24x and a long way from the 57x it reached in June:

The consensus target is $372 from 27 analysts, 73% above the last close. That’s up from $171 a year ago, though below its $416 peak in August:

On fiscal 2028 EPS of $15.78, $372 is about 24x, right at the stock’s five-year average. So the stock doesn’t need a higher multiple to get there, only for the estimates to hold.
The buyers have the better case
The sellers do have a real point in Coherent’s cash flow. In fiscal 2026 it generated $80 million of operating cash flow against $1.1 billion of capex, which left free cash flow at negative $1.0 billion. Operating cash flow was negative $92.7 million in the September quarter. Consensus still has free cash flow at negative $704 million for fiscal 2027.
Even so, I side with the buyers. Analysts have raised Coherent’s earnings estimates sharply while its multiple has dropped below its five-year average, so the stock is already priced for plenty of worry about cash.
The next test is the December-quarter report, likely in early February, when management expects its first co-packaged optics revenue. If operating cash flow turns positive there, the buyers will look right. If it’s negative again, the sellers will have their best evidence yet. The funds’ 13Fs for the December quarter, due in mid-February, will show which side kept going.
So what is Coherent stock actually worth?
TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what Coherent could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!