Key Takeaways
- Monness Crespi cut PayPal to Sell from Neutral on Nov. 18 with a $48 price target, 17% below that day’s $57.89 close.
- The firm sees 2027 EPS 7% below consensus. PayPal’s third-quarter non-GAAP EPS rose 8% because its diluted share count fell about 11%, while non-GAAP net income fell 3%.
- PayPal named a new CFO on Nov. 20, and TD Cowen now calls 2027 “another transition year.”
- At 9.9x forward earnings, PayPal already trades 35% below its five-year average, and $48 implies about 7.5x 2028 estimates.
PayPal (PYPL) picked up a Sell call on Nov. 18, after a 30% run over six months. Monness Crespi analyst Gus Gala cut the stock from Neutral with a $48 price target, 17% below that day’s $57.89 close. His 2027 EPS estimate sits 7% below consensus, even with heavy buybacks built in, according to TheFly.
Gala also noted the stock is up about 23% since the Stripe and Advent buyout bid was reported in July, though the pair walked away in August. Block (XYZ) grew gross profit 22% in the third quarter, and Affirm (AFRM) grew total volume 34%, while PayPal’s transaction margin dollars rose 2%.
PayPal’s EPS Growth Came From Buybacks
Third-quarter non-GAAP EPS rose 8% to $1.45, but non-GAAP net income fell 3% to $1.25 billion. The gap is the share count, which dropped to 858 million from 960 million. Transaction margin dollars grew $79 million, less than the $97 million drop in transaction and credit losses. Without lower losses, they would have shrunk.
Branded checkout volume growth has “remained relatively stable in the 1% to 2% range for 4 quarters,” CEO Enrique Lores said on the call.
Why Monness Doubts PayPal’s 2027
PayPal is “targeting 2027 non-GAAP EPS growth similar to this year,” Lores said. That’s about 5.5%, based on the roughly $5.60 PayPal guides for 2026 against $5.31 in 2025, and the $5.90 consensus sits right on it. Monness’s 7% haircut implies about $5.49, below this year’s guide. It’s calling for earnings to fall.
The Nov. 20 shake-up helps that case. PayPal named Xero’s Claire Bramley CFO from Feb. 3, 2027, replacing Jamie Miller, and TD Cowen told clients “2027 is set to be another transition year,” Reuters reported.
TIKR Tracks 43 Analysts on PayPal. How Many Say “Buy”?
See the full breakdown of Buy, Hold, and Sell ratings on PayPal, along with Wall Street’s revenue and earnings estimates, all in one place. More than 500,000 investors use TIKR to research stocks like this one. See PayPal’s Analyst Ratings
Does $48 Add Up?
The consensus target has already fallen to $57 from $83 a year ago, about 1% below the Nov. 18 close.

But estimates are rising. In the past 90 days, analysts lifted their 2026 EPS estimate to $5.58 from $5.38 and their 2027 estimate to $5.90 from $5.79. They see $6.41 in 2028.

Using 2028’s $6.41 as a stand-in for forward earnings a year out, $48 is about 7.5x. That’s barely above the 7.3x low PayPal hit on Feb. 12, and half its 15.2x five-year average.

PayPal Stock Is Already Priced for Slow Growth
Monness could be right about 2027. But at 9.9x forward earnings on Nov. 18, against 15.6x for Block, PayPal already trades like a slow grower. Cut 2028 by the same 7% Monness takes off 2027, and $48 is still about 8x, below today’s multiple. At today’s 9.9x, $48 would need 2028 EPS nearly a quarter below consensus.
I’d expect the stock to hold near the Street’s $57 instead.
The test is PayPal’s first 2027 outlook, due with fourth-quarter results in early February. A guide at or above $5.90 makes Monness look early. One near $5.60, flat with 2026, backs Monness’s case that $5.90 is too high.
So What Is PayPal Stock Actually Worth?
TIKR lets you forecast the future price of any stock in less than a minute. Just enter a few assumptions into TIKR’s valuation model and see what PayPal could be worth. Start from Wall Street consensus estimates, or adjust the inputs to reflect your own view of the business. It’s free to use.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!