Key Takeaways
- At a Senate hearing on Nov. 18, a former Social Security official said fixing the program with payroll taxes alone would now take 4.4% of taxable payroll, up from 1.92% in 2010.
- If that rise were split evenly between workers and employers, the way today’s tax is, a worker earning $70,000 would pay $1,540 more a year, while scrapping the wage cap would cost that worker nothing.
- A worker earning $250,000 would pay more under either fix, and a retiree with no wages would pay neither.
- Neither fix is law, so for now the thing to do is check the Social Security line on your pay stub. Anyone whose two or more employers together paid more than $184,500 this year may be able to claim excess tax back.
At a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Social Security on Nov. 18, labor economist Kathryn Anne Edwards, a senior fellow at the National Academy of Social Insurance, was asked how senators should frame the issue. For Social Security over the next 75 years, she said, “the answer is raise revenue or cut benefits.” The first two revenue ideas on her list were the ones workers would feel most directly: “Eliminate the payroll tax cap, raise the tax rate.”
Jason Fichtner, executive director of the LIMRA Retirement Income Institute and a former Social Security official, put a price on the second idea. “I’m not saying I support the solution,” he said, but fixing the program “on the payroll tax side” would have taken 1.92% of taxable payroll in 2010. “Now today, you’re at 4.4.”
If you’re still working and within 10 years or so of retiring, those two ideas would hit your paycheck very differently. If you earn less than the cap, one of them would cost you real money every year, and the other wouldn’t cost you a dime.
6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields
There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.
But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.
They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.
Today’s tax stops at the cap
Let’s take three hypothetical people: a 55-year-old earning $70,000, a worker earning $250,000 and a retiree with no wages at all. Workers pay 6.2% of their wages in Social Security tax, and their employers pay another 6.2%. That tax only applies up to a cap of $184,500 this year, which rises to $192,300 next year. Wages above the cap pay no Social Security tax, and they don’t earn any more benefits either.
So next year, the 55-year-old pays $4,340, since all of her pay is under the cap. The $250,000 earner pays 6.2% of $192,300, or $11,923, and nothing on his last $57,700. The retiree pays nothing because the tax only applies to wages. (A retiree who keeps working pays it like anyone else, and a self-employed one pays the full 12.4% himself.)
A rate rise costs her $1,540 a year
Fichtner’s 4.4% is a share of taxable payroll, meaning the wages the tax reaches. Turning it into a tax rate means deciding who pays it. So let’s say it’s split evenly, the way today’s tax is: 2.2 points more for the worker and 2.2 more for the employer.
Our 55-year-old would then pay 8.4% of $70,000, or $5,880 a year. That’s $1,540 more than she pays now, or about $128 a month. If she works 10 more years at that pay, it adds up to $15,400 out of her paychecks before she retires, and her employer pays the same again.
The $250,000 earner would pay 2.2% more on the first $192,300 of his pay, or $4,231 more a year, since the cap stays in place. The retiree with no wages still pays nothing. For that retiree, the half of Edwards’s choice to watch is the other one: cutting benefits.
No cap, no extra bill at $70,000
With no cap, the 6.2% rate stays the same and applies to every dollar of pay. Our 55-year-old never gets near the cap, so she pays exactly what she pays today. The $250,000 earner would also pay 6.2% on the $57,700 above next year’s cap, or $3,577 more a year, and his employer would match it.
That’s less than the $4,231 the rate rise would cost him, but the two bills cross at about $260,500 of pay. Above that, every extra dollar adds 6.2 cents to the no-cap bill and nothing to the rate-rise bill. Whether the newly taxed wages would also earn bigger benefits would come down to how Congress wrote the change.
My read: a no-cap plan could still come with some rate rise on top, since Edwards listed both among her ways to pay. Then our $70,000 worker would pay something after all.
Check your pay stub now
Neither fix is law, so for now the useful move is making sure you’re paying the right amount under today’s rules. The Social Security line on your pay stub (some stubs call it OASDI) should be 6.2% of your wages. If you earn more than this year’s $184,500, it should stop once you pass the cap.
If you worked for two or more employers this year and earned more than $184,500 from them together, too much may have been withheld. The IRS lets you claim the excess back as a credit on your tax return. Married couples filing jointly figure it separately for each spouse. If a single employer withheld too much, you generally can’t claim it that way.
Frankly, if you earn under the cap, I’d plan for the rate rise. It’s the only one of the two fixes that touches your paycheck, and about $128 a month is a lot easier to fit into a budget you start adjusting early.
Of course, Fichtner said a payroll-tax fix costs more the longer Congress waits: 5% of taxable payroll if it holds off until the trust fund runs out. Split evenly, that’s $1,750 a year for our 55-year-old.
Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields
Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.
Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.
We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!