Jeff Merkley on Social Security: ‘You Get Back More Than You Put In.’ At $40,000 of Pay, It Replaces 55%; at $150,000, 32%

Michael Douglass • 6 minute read
Reviewed by: Michael Douglass
Last updated Nov 20, 2026

firina from Getty Images and courtneyk from Getty Images Signature via Canva

Key Takeaways

  • At a Senate Budget Committee hearing this week, Ranking Member Jeff Merkley called Social Security part savings and part insurance. Chairman Ron Johnson said the top 10% of earners pay about 24% of the program’s payroll tax and get about 11% of its benefits.
  • Social Security’s 2027 benefit formula pays 90% of the first $1,340 of average indexed monthly earnings, 32% of earnings up to $8,077 and 15% of earnings above that.
  • A worker who turns 62 next year with a 35-year average of $40,000 gets a full benefit of about $1,844 a month, which replaces 55% of that pay. At $150,000, the benefit is about $4,025, or 32%.
  • The higher earner pays 3.8x as much Social Security tax for a check about 2.2x as big, so it’s worth checking the earnings record your own benefit will be figured from.

Who pays for Social Security, and who gets it back, became the fight at the Senate Budget Committee’s hearing, “Social Security: The Reality,” this week. Committee Chairman Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) walked through a chart of who pays the tax and who collects: “the top 10% pay approximately 24% of the payroll tax revenue. They receive about 11% of the benefit from Social Security.”

Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), the committee’s ranking member, said much of his colleague’s case came down to the fact that “he does not like the way Social Security is structured.” Then he described the structure himself: “It’s part savings, it’s part insurance. If you do very well, you don’t get all that money back. You don’t do so well, you’re less affluent. You get back more than you put in.”

The two senators were looking at the same thing from opposite sides. It’s built into the formula behind every retirement check, so it helps to know where your own earnings put you.

6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields

There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.

But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.

They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.

Two workers, one formula

Take two hypothetical workers who turn 62 next year. That makes 2027 their first year of eligibility. One worker’s best 35 years of earnings average $40,000, and the other’s average $150,000. Social Security indexes each past year’s pay to wages before it picks the highest 35, so both averages are in today’s wage terms. In an average year, each worker paid 6.2% of pay in Social Security tax: $2,480 for the first and $9,300 for the second. Their employers paid another 6.2% on top.

The first $1,340 a month counts the most

Social Security starts from average indexed monthly earnings, which are those 35 years averaged by the month. For anyone first eligible in 2027, the full benefit is 90% of the first $1,340 of that average, plus 32% of anything from $1,340 through $8,077, plus 15% of anything above $8,077. The year a worker first becomes eligible locks in those dollar lines, no matter when they actually claim. The result is the benefit at full retirement age. That’s 67 for anyone born in 1960 or later, which includes both of these workers.

About $1,844 a month on $40,000, about $4,025 on $150,000

Here’s each worker’s benefit, band by band:

Metric$40,000 worker$150,000 worker
Average indexed monthly earnings$3,333$12,500
90% of the first $1,340$1,206$1,206
32% from $1,340 to $8,077$638$2,156
15% above $8,077$0$663
Full benefit at 67, a monthabout $1,844about $4,025
Share of average pay replaced55%32%
Worker’s 6.2% tax in an average year$2,480$9,300

Source: Social Security’s 2027 benefit formula; TIKR’s math.

Both workers get the same $1,206 for their first $1,340 a month. After that, each dollar of the higher earner’s pay adds 32 cents, and only 15 cents above $8,077. So the $150,000 worker paid 3.8x as much Social Security tax for a check about 2.2x as big. In dollars, that’s the gap on Johnson’s chart and the “insurance element” Merkley described.

Both checks will be bigger by 67, since cost-of-living adjustments start in 2027, the year these workers turn 62. And Social Security figures what a spouse, a widow or widower, or the children can collect from that same full benefit, so the same lean toward lower earners carries over to their families.

Your own 35 years

Your replacement rate depends on your own highest 35 years. So the first thing to check is the earnings record Social Security will average, which your Social Security statement at ssa.gov lists year by year. A year that’s missing or understated lowers your average. If you keep working, a year that beats one of your lowest 35 takes its place. Keep in mind that these are full-retirement-age figures: claim before 67 and the check is smaller for life, or wait past it and the check grows.

Frankly, if you’ve averaged something like $40,000, Social Security will likely cover more of your retirement than your savings alone would suggest. That makes when you claim one of the biggest money decisions you’ll make. Nearer $150,000, plan on it covering about a third of your pay, and lean on your own savings for the rest. Of course, Congress can change the formula, and this week’s hearing showed lawmakers are arguing over it. For now, this is the rule for anyone turning 62 next year.

Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields

Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.

Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.

We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.

Learn more here.

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required