Better High-Yield Dividend Stock: Plains All American vs. Energy Transfer

Gian Estrada • 5 minute read
Reviewed by: David Hanson
Last updated Nov 14, 2026

Nickel_Bell and Aaron Hawkins from Getty Images via Canva

Key Takeaways

  • Energy Transfer raised its distribution for the 20th quarter in a row, and Plains All American’s latest distribution is 10% above a year earlier.
  • Plains has raised faster since 2020, but its distributable cash flow coverage has fallen every year since then, to 1.7x in fiscal 2025.
  • On fiscal 2026 consensus, Energy Transfer covers its distribution 2.2x against 1.6x for Plains.

Energy Transfer (ET) raised its quarterly distribution to $0.3425 a unit, which the company called “the Partnership’s twentieth consecutive increase to its quarterly cash distribution.”

Plains All American Pipeline (PAA) declared $0.4175 a unit on Oct. 1, 10% more than a year earlier. Plains yields 6.9% and Energy Transfer 7.0%, and both pay on partnership units that come with a K-1.

So which is the better high-yield dividend stock?

MetricPlains All American (PAA)Energy Transfer (ET)
Yield at the current rate6.9%7.0%
Annual distribution$1.67 a unit$1.37 a unit
Distribution growth, fiscal 2020-202516.7% a year7.8% a year
Distributable cash flow coverage, fiscal 20251.7x1.8x
Distributable cash flow coverage, fiscal 2026 consensus1.6x2.2x
Net debt/EBITDA3.7x3.8x
Interest coverage2.8x3.1x

Sources: TIKR, and StockAnalysis for yields at the current distribution rate, at today’s prices. Debt and interest coverage are for the last twelve months.

6 Safe Dividend Stocks Paying Retirees 6%+ Yields

There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.

But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.

They’re all yours for free as part of our new investment report, which you can access right here.

Plains Raises Fast on a Thinning Cushion

Plains sold its Canadian NGL business in May 2026, leaving it mostly a crude oil company. Third-quarter adjusted EBITDA rose 6% to $711 million, and its full-year guidance implies about $700 million in the fourth quarter.

Management’s payout plan is “targeted $0.15 per unit annual increases.” After cuts from $2.50 a unit in fiscal 2016, distributions rose from $0.72 in fiscal 2020 to $1.56 in fiscal 2025, while distributable cash flow per unit went only from $2.31 to $2.61:

Bar chart from TIKR of Plains All American Pipeline's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025.
PAA Distributions vs. Distributable Cash Flow Per Unit: 2016-2025 (TIKR)

So coverage fell every year, from 3.2x in fiscal 2020 to a still-comfortable 1.7x in fiscal 2025, and consensus has 1.6x for fiscal 2026.

Energy Transfer Has Room to Spare

Energy Transfer raises more slowly. Management said on its second-quarter call that it’s “targeting a long-term annual distribution growth rate of 3% to 5%.”

Its business is growing much faster. Third-quarter adjusted EBITDA rose 31% to $5.03 billion, and 2026 guidance increased to $19.7 billion to $19.9 billion from $18.8 billion to $19.1 billion. Management attributed the higher outlook to stronger base-business performance, market volatility and a one-time $285 million benefit from previously disputed natural gas purchases.

Its distributions have rebuilt from a cut, to $1.34 a unit in fiscal 2025 from $0.63 in fiscal 2021. Its cushion thinned too, from 2.4x coverage in fiscal 2022 to 1.8x in fiscal 2025:

Bar chart from TIKR of Energy Transfer's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025.
ET Distributions vs. Distributable Cash Flow Per Unit: 2016-2025 (TIKR)

Why Energy Transfer Gets the Edge

Energy Transfer is the better high-yield dividend stock. Its check is a hair bigger today, and consensus has far more cash behind it: distributable cash flow per unit rising to $2.94 in fiscal 2026 from $2.38, while the distribution rises to $1.37.

Bar chart from TIKR of Energy Transfer's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow (DCF) per unit, actual and consensus estimates, $ per unit, fiscal 2023-2028.
ET Distributions vs. Distributable Cash Flow Per Unit, Actual and Estimates: 2023-2028 (TIKR)

Part of that jump is market volatility, which management has credited with upside for three quarters running, and consensus dips to $2.89 in fiscal 2027. Even so, coverage stays above 2x through fiscal 2028 on those estimates.

Plains’ case is its raises. $10,000 pays $690 a year in Plains today and $700 in Energy Transfer. If Plains keeps adding $0.15 a unit a year and Energy Transfer raises 3.0% a year, its latest pace, Plains’ check passes Energy Transfer’s next year and reaches about $1,248 in year 10, against about $914.

But a fixed $0.15 raise is a smaller percentage every year, and it keeps landing on a thinner cushion. I’d rather own the 7% check with more than twice the cash behind it on 2026 estimates, knowing the gap narrows if the volatility fades.

Forget Energy Transfer: 6 Safe 6%+ Dividend Yields You Can Buy Right Now

Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.

Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.

We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now. (And Energy Transfer isn’t one of them.)

Learn more here.

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required