Better Dividend Stock: Realty Income vs. Americold Realty Trust

Roxanna Maglangit • 6 minute read
Reviewed by: Michael Douglass
Last updated Nov 18, 2026

@AnthonyRosenberg from Getty Images Signature via Canva; @Изображения пользователя Maximusnd Zahar via Canva

Key Takeaways

  • Realty Income yields 5.6% and Americold Realty Trust yields 5.5%, and both raised their 2026 AFFO per share guidance with their third-quarter results.
  • Americold’s dividend took 64% of its fiscal 2025 AFFO, against 75% for Realty Income’s, and analysts expect those ratios to move to 70% and 73% in fiscal 2026.
  • Analysts expect Realty Income’s AFFO per share to rise in 2026 and Americold’s to fall, after Americold put 12 warehouses into a joint venture to pay down $1.15 billion of debt.
  • Both stocks trade at about 13x forward AFFO, so price doesn’t separate them.

Realty Income (O) raised its monthly dividend again on Nov. 10, to $0.2740 a share from $0.2715. That’s its 137th increase since its 1994 NYSE listing, and it came after the REIT lifted its 2026 AFFO per share guidance.

Americold Realty Trust (COLD) raised its AFFO guidance too. But its third-quarter dividend stayed at $0.23 a share.

Both yield about 5.5%. So which is the better dividend stock?

MetricRealty Income (O)Americold Realty Trust (COLD)
Dividend yield5.6%5.5%
Dividend growth, fiscal 2020-20252.9% a year1.8% a year
AFFO payout ratio, fiscal 202575%64%
AFFO payout ratio, fiscal 2026 consensus73%70%
Forward price/AFFO13x13x
Source: TIKR. Yields at today’s prices

6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields

There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.

But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.

They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.

Realty Income keeps growing into its dividend

Realty Income’s third-quarter AFFO rose 3.7% from a year earlier to $1.12 a share. It invested $2.6 billion in the quarter. It’s also selling less stock to pay for that growth: public equity funded 19% of its investment volume this year through September, against a 47% average over the past three years.

Its AFFO per share has grown faster than its dividend over the past decade:

Bar chart from TIKR of Realty Income's dividends per share vs. adjusted FFO (AFFO) per share, $ per share, fiscal 2016–2025.
Realty Income (O): dividends per share vs. adjusted FFO (AFFO) per share, $ per share, fiscal 2016–2025 (TIKR)

That took its AFFO payout ratio from 83% in fiscal 2016 to a comfortable 75% in fiscal 2025. Consensus has it at 73% for fiscal 2026, on $4.45 of AFFO per share, in line with the company’s raised guidance.

The main risk is about $2.9 billion of debt due in 2027 at a rate under 3%, which will need to be refinanced at today’s higher rates. On Nov. 12, it also said Neil Abraham, its chief strategy officer and the president of its international business, will leave at the end of the year, a real loss with Europe at 42% of its investment volume in the quarter.

Americold traded some AFFO for a stronger balance sheet

Where Realty Income is adding properties, Americold has spent 2026 shrinking its portfolio to pay down debt. It closed its EQT joint venture in the third quarter, putting 12 warehouses into it and keeping a 30% stake. The deal cut its debt by $1.15 billion and brought its leverage down a full turn, to 6.2x, the company said on its third-quarter call.

Same-store warehouse revenue rose 5.7% in the third quarter from a year earlier, and the same-store services margin hit a record 15.9%, up from 13.6%. “We are not relying on a recovery in demand to create value,” CFO Christopher Papa said in August. “Instead, we are laser-focused on executing against the priorities that are within our control.”

Its dividend sat at $0.88 a share for four fiscal years while its AFFO per share swung around beneath it:

Bar chart from TIKR of Americold Realty Trust's dividends per share vs. adjusted FFO (AFFO) per share, $ per share, fiscal 2017-2025.
Americold Realty Trust (COLD): dividends per share vs. adjusted FFO (AFFO) per share, $ per share, fiscal 2017-2025 (TIKR)

Its AFFO payout ratio was 64% in fiscal 2025, down from a peak of 79% in fiscal 2022. Consensus has AFFO per share falling from $1.43 in fiscal 2025 to $1.32 in fiscal 2026, which would lift the payout ratio to a still well-covered 70%. Management expects AFFO per share to hit its low in the first quarter of 2027 and build through the year.

The main risk is demand: management says consumers are still under pressure, and expects retailers consolidating their logistics to hurt its occupancy and throughput at the start of 2027.

So which dividend wins?

Realty Income is the better dividend stock. Its AFFO per share is rising, its payout ratio is falling, and it has raised its dividend for more than three decades.

$10,000 in Realty Income pays $560 a year today. At its 2.9% five-year growth rate, that becomes about $725 in year 10: call it a 7.2% yield on your cash. The same $10,000 in Americold pays $550 and grows to about $648 at its 1.8% rate. If Americold could repeat its 4.5% raise from fiscal 2025, its income would pass Realty Income’s within about a year. But that raise followed four flat years, and analysts expect its AFFO per share to fall this year.

You also aren’t paying up for Realty Income’s steadier growth:

Line chart from TIKR of Realty Income's forward (NTM) price/AFFO, last 5 years.
Realty Income (O): forward (NTM) price/AFFO, last 5 years (TIKR)

At 13x forward AFFO, Realty Income trades below its five-year average of 15x and at about the same multiple as Americold.

None of this means Americold’s dividend is in trouble. It takes a smaller share of AFFO than Realty Income’s, and Piper Sandler upgraded the stock to Overweight on Nov. 13, citing its turnaround. Still, I’d rather own the dividend whose cash flow is climbing.

If Americold’s AFFO builds through 2027 the way management expects and the board starts raising again, this gap could close quickly.

Forget Realty Income: 6 safe 6%+ dividend yields you can buy right now

Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.

Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.

We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now. (And Realty Income isn’t one of them.)

Learn more here.

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required