Key Takeaways
- A retired couple, 57 and 55, called the Money Matters podcast with $1 million in 457 plans and a $2 million rollover IRA, and Pat McClain told them the 457 money can be spent without penalty.
- Withdrawals from a governmental 457(b) before 59½ don’t owe the 10% additional tax. IRA withdrawals before 59½ do.
- Taking $80,000 a year from the IRA instead of the 457 would add $8,000 a year in extra tax until 59½, on top of regular income tax.
- Early retirees should confirm their 457 is a government plan before counting on the exception, and think twice before rolling it into an IRA.
If you’ve retired early with money in both a 457 and an IRA, the account you spend from first can be worth thousands of dollars a year. And for a lot of people, it’s the smaller one.
A couple who called the Money Matters podcast this weekend has exactly that setup.
The couple already knew the rule
The callers are 57 and 55. They retired at 55 and 52, and their pensions pay about $130,000 a year combined, which they said is roughly what they spend. On top of that, they have a $2 million rollover IRA, $1 million across the 457 plans they each have, a $500,000 brokerage account and about $600,000 in savings and CDs. They called to ask how to keep down the tax on their required minimum distributions, which start at 75.
Partway through the call, Pat McClain asked whose 457 it was. Then he pointed out that they’d been talking about waiting until 59½ to spend, when “the 457 is completely accessible without penalty.” Their reply: “Yeah, we understand that.”
Good for them. I suspect plenty of early retirees don’t know this, and it’s real money.
6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields
There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.
But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.
They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.
No 10% tax on a government 457
If you take money out of an IRA or a 401(k) before 59½, you usually owe a 10% additional tax on top of regular income tax. Governmental 457(b) plans, the ones state and local governments offer, are the exception: withdrawals from them before 59½ don’t owe the 10% at all. The one catch is money that was rolled into the 457 from another type of plan or an IRA. That part still owes the 10% when it comes out.
And it doesn’t matter when you left the job. That’s a big deal for this couple, since one of them retired at 52. Under the rule of 55, 401(k) money is free of the 10% only for someone who left the job in or after the calendar year they turned 55, and the rule never applies to an IRA.
$8,000 a year for spending from the wrong account
The callers didn’t say they need anything beyond their pensions. So let’s say they want to spend an extra $80,000 a year until 59½. They’d owe regular income tax on that $80,000 whichever account it came from, so the 10% is the only difference:
| Metric | From the 457 | From the IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Withdrawal | $80,000 | $80,000 |
| Regular income tax | Owed | Owed |
| 10% additional tax | $0 | $8,000 |
That’s $8,000 a year in extra tax on the IRA withdrawal, every year until the IRA’s owner turns 59½. If the money came from the 55-year-old’s IRA, that’s roughly four more years of it, or about $30,000 in all. Four years of $80,000 withdrawals from the 457 add up to $320,000, about a third of its $1 million.
Spend the 457 first, if it’s a government plan
The callers never said whether their 457s are governmental, and tax-exempt employers offer non-governmental 457(b)s too. The exception only covers government plans. So anyone in their shoes should first confirm which kind they have with the plan, and also check the plan’s own rules on how and when they can take money out. Moving the money is the other trap. If you roll a 457 into an IRA, it comes out as IRA money, 10% and all, until 59½. That’s worth knowing if you’re thinking about consolidating accounts before the year ends.
Bottom line: if your 457 is a government plan and you’re under 59½, it’s the retirement account I’d spend from first, and I’d leave the IRA alone until then. Once you pass 59½, the 10% no longer applies to the IRA either. For this couple, the bigger question then is the one they called about: the RMDs coming at 75.
Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields
Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.
Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.
We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!


