Better Dividend Stock for Retirees: Plains All American vs. MPLX

Roxanna Maglangit • 6 minute read
Reviewed by: Michael Douglass
Last updated Nov 16, 2026

@Rulles from Getty Images via Canva, @Aflo Images from アフロ(Aflo) via Canva

Key Takeaways

  • MPLX raised its distribution 12.5% in October, the third year in a row at that rate, and Plains All American’s latest quarterly payment is up 10% from a year earlier.
  • MPLX yields 8.7% and Plains All American yields 6.9%, but Plains has more room to cover its payout: 1.7x distributable cash flow in fiscal 2025, against 1.4x for MPLX.
  • Over the 10 years to fiscal 2025, MPLX’s distribution grew 8.4% a year, and Plains All American’s shrank 5.6% a year.
  • MPLX’s $750 million asset sale could slow its 2027 raise, and Plains All American will give its 2027 guidance in February.

Pipeline partnerships pay some of the biggest checks a retiree can find, and both of these just paid more. On Oct. 27, MPLX (MPLX) raised its quarterly distribution 12.5% to $1.2111 a unit. That’s the third year in a row it has raised by that much, and the stock now yields 8.7%.

On Oct. 1, Plains All American Pipeline (PAA) declared $0.4175 a unit for the third quarter. That’s 10% more than a year earlier, for a 6.9% yield. Both are MLPs, so holders get distributions on their units and a K-1 at tax time.

MPLX pays more, but Plains holds back more of its cash. For a retiree who wants a dividend check they can count on, which is the better buy?

MetricPlains All American (PAA)MPLX (MPLX)
Yield6.9%8.7%
Distribution growth, fiscal 2020-202516.7% a year8.2% a year
Distribution growth, fiscal 2015-2025-5.6% a year8.4% a year
Distributable cash flow coverage, fiscal 20251.7x1.4x
Distributable cash flow coverage, fiscal 2026 consensus1.6x1.3x
Net debt/EBITDA3.7x4.1x
Interest coverage2.8x4.0x
Source: TIKR; yields at today’s prices

6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields

There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.

But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.

They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.

Plains is a crude oil business again

Plains sold its Canadian NGL business to Keyera in May. It expects its crude oil segment to earn about $370 million more in 2026 than in 2025, growth of about 16% that includes a full year from the Cactus III acquisition.

Plains’ distribution fell from $2.50 a unit in fiscal 2016 to $0.72 in fiscal 2020, then rose every year after fiscal 2021, reaching $1.56 in fiscal 2025.

Bar chart from TIKR of Plains All American Pipeline's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025.
Plains All American Pipeline (PAA): distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025 (TIKR)

Rebuilding the payout has used up much of the cushion. Coverage went from 3.2x in fiscal 2020 to 1.7x in fiscal 2025, which is still well-covered, and analysts expect 1.6x in fiscal 2026. That’s plenty of room for management’s target of $0.15-a-unit raises each year.

The near term is softer, though. On Nov. 6, Plains guided to about $700 million of fourth-quarter adjusted EBITDA, below the third quarter’s $711 million.

MPLX pays more on a thinner cushion

Plains rebuilt its payout, but MPLX kept raising its own. Its natural gas and NGL business is growing on volume: Utica gathering and processing volumes rose 19% and 20% from a year earlier. MPLX said on its call that the latest raise “marks the fifth consecutive year of double-digit increases.”

MPLX’s distribution rose from $2.05 a unit in fiscal 2016 to $4.07 in fiscal 2025, and its distributable cash flow per unit grew with it, from $3.25 to $5.68:

Bar chart from TIKR of MPLX's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025.
MPLX (MPLX): distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow per unit, $ per unit, fiscal 2016–2025 (TIKR)

Coverage hasn’t dropped below 1.3x in any fiscal year on that chart, and it was 1.4x in fiscal 2025. Management says it’s comfortable with annual coverage of 1.3x.

The risk is a slower raise. On Nov. 2, MPLX agreed to sell the logistics assets tied to two Marathon Petroleum refineries to CVR Energy for $750 million. Maryann Mannen, MPLX’s chairman, president and CEO, said on the call that the sale “currently presents a headwind to 2027 that was not initially contemplated when other operational metrics were established.” Management still expects a significant 2027 raise, bigger than its growth in distributable cash flow, though maybe not another 12.5%.

So which dividend wins?

For retirees, I’d take MPLX. It pays the bigger check: $870 a year on $10,000, against $690 from Plains. Over the 10 years to fiscal 2025, its distribution grew 8.4% a year while Plains’ shrank 5.6% a year.

MPLX’s cushion will keep thinning. Analysts expect its distribution to climb from $4.07 a unit in fiscal 2025 to $5.40 in fiscal 2028, faster than its distributable cash flow per unit, which they see rising from $5.68 to $6.58:

Bar chart from TIKR of MPLX's distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow (DCF) per unit, actual and consensus estimates, $ per unit, fiscal 2023-2028.
MPLX (MPLX): distributions per unit vs. distributable cash flow (DCF) per unit, actual and consensus estimates, $ per unit, fiscal 2023-2028 (TIKR)

Plains still has a real case. Its cushion is wider, its leverage is lower, and its payout is growing faster right now. At each one’s fiscal 2025 pace (17.3% for Plains, 12.7% for MPLX), $10,000 in Plains would out-earn MPLX in about six years, around 2032. But that’s a long wait for a retiree. Plains’ latest payment is also only 10% above a year earlier, so its growth is already slowing. MPLX has the record a retiree can count on.

Of course, MPLX’s next raise will show how much the asset sale costs it, and Plains gives its 2027 guidance in February.

Forget MPLX: 6 safe 6%+ dividend yields you can buy right now

Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.

Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.

We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now. (And MPLX isn’t one of them.)

Learn more here.

Disclaimer:

Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!

Join thousands of investors worldwide who use TIKR to supercharge their investment analysis.

Sign Up for FREENo credit card required