Key Takeaways
- A poster in their mid-50s on the r/personalfinance subreddit pays about $650 a month, or $7,800 a year, in interest on $50,000 of credit card debt at 29%.
- Regular Roth IRA contributions come out first and owe no income tax or 10% additional tax at any age. Earnings taken out before 59½ owe both.
- If $20,000 of a $50,000 withdrawal is earnings, a single filer in the 22% bracket owes $6,400 once, which is less than one year of the card interest.
- Taking out only the contributions costs nothing in tax. Either move works only if the spending behind the balance stops.
Americans’ credit card balances rose $22 billion in the third quarter to a record $1.29 trillion, according to the New York Fed’s latest household debt report. If you’re carrying some of that at close to 30% and you have a Roth IRA, it’s hard not to look at the Roth and wonder.
Part of a Roth can come out without costing a dime in tax, which is good news for anyone in that spot. The rest can get expensive, so it’s worth knowing which dollars are which before you touch it.
6 safe dividend stocks paying retirees 6%+ yields
There are over 100 stocks paying 6%+ annual dividends today.
But after an extensive investment review leveraging TIKR’s proprietary data, we now believe only six of them are truly safe for retirees.
They’re all yours as part of our new investment report. Learn more about how to get access right here.
$650 a month, straight to the card companies
That’s the bind a poster in r/personalfinance described over the weekend: $50,000 of credit card debt at 29%, against $500,000 in retirement savings. They’re in their mid-50s and make about $95,000 a year. Their mortgage is $2,700 a month and their cars are paid off. They’ve been moving balances to a 0% card about $15,000 at a time, and they’re still paying about $650 a month in interest. That comes to $7,800 a year in card interest.
They asked: “Would it be better to pay off the cards with retirement funds from a Roth IRA and not use them or am I making more in the fund?”
Very little in a retirement account can be counted on to earn 29% a year, so what matters is what pulling the money out would cost. The post doesn’t say how much of the $500,000 is in the Roth. So let’s say the Roth holds at least $50,000: $30,000 of regular contributions the poster put in over the years, and $20,000 of growth on top. And say they file single.
Contributions come out first, and they come out free
A Roth IRA withdrawal follows a set order. Regular contributions come out first, then conversions and rollovers on a first-in, first-out basis, and earnings come out last. A return of your regular contributions isn’t counted as income, and the 10% additional tax applies only to the taxable part of a withdrawal. So contributions come back out with no tax and no penalty, at any age.
Earnings work differently. They come out tax-free only once you’ve reached 59½ and five years have passed since the first tax year you contributed to a Roth. If you take them sooner, they’re taxed as income and the 10% additional tax goes on top. If any of your Roth came from a conversion, each conversion has its own five-year clock before the 10% tax stops applying to it.
The Roth is also the cheapest part of the $500,000 to start with. Money taken from a 401(k) before 59½ is taxed as income, and the 10% additional tax usually applies on top of that.
$6,400 once, against $7,800 a year
If the poster pulls the whole $50,000, the first $30,000 comes back as contributions, with no tax and no penalty. The last $20,000 is earnings, and it’s added to the $95,000 salary for the year. After the standard deduction, a single filer earning that much is already in the 22% bracket, which covers taxable income from $50,400 to $105,700 in 2026, and the extra $20,000 stays inside it. That means the earnings cost $4,400 in income tax plus $2,000 for the 10% additional tax, so $6,400 between the two.
That’s a one-time bill of $6,400, against $7,800 a year in card interest. Waiting until 59½ to get the earnings out tax-free costs more. If the poster is four years away, that’s $31,200 of interest at today’s pace.
Taking out only the $30,000 of contributions costs nothing in tax. That leaves $20,000 on the cards to pay down from the paycheck.
What the poster gives up is the tax-free growth on whatever leaves the Roth. And since Roth contributions are capped each year, money taken out now can’t simply go back in later.
The cards have to stay paid off
The poster had already reached the same conclusion. In an update to the post, they wrote: “I need to be a lot smarter about what I’m spending money on.” That matters more than the tax bill. If the Roth goes to pay off cards that then fill back up, the poster ends up with the debt and without the savings.
Pulling the money out also gives up some protection. In bankruptcy, federal law shields retirement money from creditors while it stays in the account, with IRA and Roth IRA assets protected up to $1,711,975 for cases filed from April 1, 2025. Once the money goes to a card company, that protection is gone.
Here’s where I land: I’d pull the $30,000 of contributions now, since it costs nothing, and throw every spare dollar of the paycheck at the last $20,000. Paying $6,400 to clear it all at once is still cheaper than another year at $650 a month, so that’s fine too, as long as the cards stay at zero. Of course, the tax on the earnings goes away entirely at 59½, as long as five years have passed since the poster’s first Roth contribution. If the spending is under control, the $20,000 of growth can wait until then.
Enjoy your retirement in style with these safe 6%+ dividend yields
Dividends can hold the key to enormous wealth. But only if you buy the right ones.
Picking the right high-yield dividend stock can be the difference between a dream retirement…and scraping by every month, waiting for the next Social Security check to clear.
We’ve identified six stocks yielding 6%+ that we believe every retiree should know about right now.
Disclaimer:
Please note that the articles on TIKR are not intended to serve as investment or financial advice from TIKR or our content team, nor are they recommendations to buy or sell any stocks. We create our content based on TIKR Terminal’s investment data and analysts’ estimates. Our analysis might not include recent company news or important updates. TIKR has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Thank you for reading, and happy investing!